Over the history of the superhero genre, there have been movies in the MCU, the DCU, and beyond which have been so bad as to actually become good. After the movies of the MCU elevated superhero movies to the pinnacle of modern cinema in terms of box office success, it might seem hard to remember a time in which the genre wasn’t a dominant force within pop culture. However, there were days when superhero movies weren’t as popular, as the genre once had a reputation for being particularly disappointing.
Long before the start of the MCU’s movie timeline – as well as on a few notable occasions since – there were a number of truly awful superhero movies. Interestingly, some of these movies were actually so bad as to sort of become good, as they prove enjoyable in spite of their many faults. Though it’s undeniable that the following movies are far from positive entries into the genre, they’re all still bizarrely good in their own unique ways.
10 Hancock (2008)
Close
Though it might be unfair to summarily label 2008’s Hancock a bad superhero movie, it’s still far from a good one by many metrics. The film’s plot is formulaic and unoriginal, and leans heavily on countless tired tropes from across multiple genres. The resulting movie is hardly the groundbreaking examination of superhero stories it seems to think it is, lending it the vague air of a poor entry into the superhero genre.
However, in spite of its narrative faults, Hancock is actually a great movie. Its lack of originality works in its favor in some ways, as it makes it an accessible entry into the genre for those less versed in superhero cinema. The performances of Will Smith, Charlize Theron, and Jason Bateman all help legitimize Hancock, and for all its faults and its lack of originality, it’s still somehow a good movie.
9 Ghost Rider: Spirit Of Vengeance (2011)
Close
The 2011 follow-up to the painfully average 2007 movie Ghost Rider, the Nicolas Cage-led Marvel sequel was a disaster in many respects. As well as being critically panned for its script, CGI, and the performances of many of its cast members, Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance proved a premature end to the character’s planned live-action franchise. The many issues with the movie are well-documented, but its more positive elements are regularly overlooked.
Somewhere in its overcooked performances, bizarre visual choices, and hilariously wooden script, Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance actually becomes an entertaining movie. Nicolas Cage’s performance alternates between extremely frenetic to dour from scene to scene, adding an extra layer of entertainment value to the ill-informed sequel. Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance is one of those superhero movies so bad that it actually becomes good, albeit in an incredibly unintentional way.
8 Blade: Trinity (2004)
Close
Widely considered the worst Blade movie by a considerable margin, 2004’s Blade: Trinity earned the ire of many critics and audiences upon its release. Issues with its production have since been well-documented, including disagreements between its cast reportedly leading to on-set incidents. The resulting film is by far the weakest of the Blade trilogy, and is broadly thought of as an especially bad entry into the superhero genre.
Considering Blade: Trinity purely on its own merits, though, it does possess a certain charm. It fluctuates rapidly between self-seriousness and quirky comedic quips, providing a strange dichotomy of tones between scenes. For all its faults, Blade: Trinity possesses a handful of memorable moments and charismatic performances from some of its stars, making it one of the best terrible superhero movies in the history of the genre.
7 Batman & Robin (1997)
Close
Having rightfully earned its as-yet undisputed titled as the worst Batman movie ever made, 1997’s Batman & Robin is not fondly remembered by many. The movie, led by George Clooney in his debut as the Caped Crusader, concerned Batman, Robin, and Batgirl as they faced the combined forces of Poison Ivy and Mr. Freeze. Joel Schumacher’s Batman sequel was panned by critics, and has earned a place in superhero movie history as an especially poor piece of comic book cinema.
Putting aside the movie’s mishandling of the source material, it can be considered so bad that it’s actually good. Its lack of seriousness could be considered playful wackiness, and it certainly serves as a more family-friendly adaptation of the Dark Knight’s world. Though it’s far from award-winning cinema, Batman & Robin’s entertainment value is often unfairly overlooked due to its poor reputation among Batman fans, deserved though it might be.
6 Morbius (2022)
Close
With Academy Award winner Jared Leto at the head of the cast of Morbius, the movie may have seemed at a glance to be destined for success. However, the release of its trailer led to widespread ridicule, with the movie then being panned by critics upon its release. Morbius’s negative reception and the wealth of jokes at the film’s expense ultimately contributed to its reputation as one of the worst Marvel movies ever made.
Interestingly, it’s exactly that reputation that allows Morbius to become so bad it’s good. What should have been serious moments in the movie are instead ridiculous and laughable, but this all contributes to its status as a film that seems to be a parody of itself. As audiences largely went into Morbius with staggeringly low expectations, the movie was able to earn some degree of success due to its poor reputation.
5 Daredevil (2003)
Close
2003 saw the release of Daredevil, considered by some to be the quintessential pre-MCU Marvel movie in all the wrong ways. With Ben Affleck as the titular superhero, Daredevil also featured Jennifer Garner, Colin Farrell, and Michael Clarke Duncan in supporting roles. Earning largely negative reviews and an even worse reputation, 2003’s Daredevil has long since come to be considered a terrible entry into the superhero genre.
This isn’t entirely true, though. For all its faults, Daredevil possesses a singular early-’00s edginess that translates into a quirky kind of charm. It’s needlessly dark and nowhere near as gritty as it seems to think itself, but Daredevil features some enjoyable action set pieces and a generally entertaining adaptation of its Marvel characters. Though it’s undeniably a bad Marvel movie, 2003’s Daredevil is somehow still a fun and occasionally ridiculous addition to Marvel’s cinematic legacy.
4 The League Of Extraordinary Gentlemen (2003)
Close
Though a loose adaptation of its comic book source material, 2003’s The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen was undoubtedly based on a team of unlikely heroes originating in the comics. The resulting movie left much to be desired, and was lambasted by critics on multiple fronts. It also boasts the unfortunate accolade of single-handedly ending Sean Connery’s otherwise legendary acting career according to the actor himself due to his poor experience of making the film.
Even so, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is a unique movie. Its mashup of literary heroes and villains from the Victorian Era makes for an interesting style, which translates well into the movie’s visual approach to the adaptation. Despite an unreasonable amount of narrative inconsistency, the film’s action set pieces are engaging and memorable, and for all of its ridiculousness, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen somehow manages to be entertaining nonetheless.
3 Spawn (1997)
Close
Despite having earned something of a cult following, 1997’s Spawn is not remembered as a particularly good superhero movie. Critical reactions to the movie were largely negative, and Spawn’s poor use of the time’s limited CGI technology has only further hurt the movie’s reputation over the years since its release. For all of its negative aspects, however, Spawn is able to stand out as another superhero movie that’s so bad it’s actually good.
Spawn’s plot is not particularly well-written, and its visuals often lead much to be desired. Even so, it’s a fun and quirky adaptation of the source material, and features several memorable moments of brutal violence that struck a chord with long-time fans of the character. Despite being objectively poor in a general sense, 1997’s Spawn actually stands out as unfairly judged in many ways, as it’s nowhere near as bad as its reputation suggests.
2 Madame Web (2024)
Close
Released in 2024 as part of Sony’s Spider-Man Universe, Madame Web is one of the worst comic book movies in recent memory. The criticisms of the movie are as varied as they are numerous, and by no stretch of the imagination can it can be considered a good film. Therein lies its charm, however, as watching it with its poor quality in mind actually makes Madame Web a far more positive experience.
A poor script and several seemingly uninterested performances from Madame Web’s cast make it an unintentionally hilarious watch. There are many points where the movie seems to take itself all too seriously, despite the ridiculousness of the events unfolding onscreen. This leads to Madame Web’s justified reputation as a comic book movie that’s so bad it’s good, as it perfectly feeds into the lack of quality that its audience is able to laugh at even through its worst moments.
1 Judge Dredd (1995)
Close
The first major live-action adaptation of the iconic Judge Dredd seems on paper to be a blockbuster affair, with Sylvester Stallone lending A-list star power to the role. However, the movie very quickly dispels any notion of comic-accuracy, proving almost offensive to long-standing fans of the character, while also taking a narrative nosedive into nonsensical territory. However, there is one key aspect of the movie that actually makes it so bad that it’s good.
The apparent misreading of the source material shines through in the serious portrayal of Dredd himself. By taking the character so seriously as a hero, the movie becomes a strangely meta comment on Dredd’s real-life origins, as he was intended to be a parody of exactly the kind of authoritarian action hero he became in his first big screen outing. As such, 1995’s Judge Dredd unintentionally joins the ranks of the superhero movies from the MCU and the DCU that are so bad that they’re actually good.
Upcoming MCU Movies
Upcoming DC Movie Releases